I actually used this every day this month and most days last month. It is perfect for every day. It is not as harsh looking as a pure black and it has a touch of sparkle, but it certainly does not look glittery. I lasts really well and I love that I don't need to sharpen it!
Revlon Wet/Dry Shadow in Gilded
Maybelline Color Tattoo in Bad to the Bronze
The upper left is Bad to the Bronze alone and the lower right is Gilded layered over Bad to the Bronze. I don't know if Gilded is still available, but I think any creamy champagne colored shadow would look beautiful over Bad to the Bronze.
Have you tried any of my favorites?